Middle States Association of Colleges and Schools
| New York | Pennsylvania |
| D'Youville College | Cabrini College |
| Manhattan College | Immaculata College |
| New Jersey | |
| Felician College | |
New England Association of Colleges and Schools
| New Hampshire | Connecticut |
| Daniel Webster College | Charter Oak State College |
Higher Learning Commission of the North Central Association
of Schools and Colleges
| Arkansas | Kansas |
| Philander Smith College | Central Christian College |
| Nebraska |
| Illinois | Concordia University |
| Concordia University (IL) | Ohio |
| Kendall College | Tiffin University (x2) |
| North Park College | Wilberforce University |
| Trinity Christian College |
|
| Indiana | Michigan |
| Anderson University (x2) | Northwood University |
| Bethel College (IN) | St. Mary's College |
| Huntington College | West Virginia |
Iowa
| Ohio Valley College |
Briar Cliff University
| Wisconsin |
| Missouri | Viterbo University |
| Hannibal-La Grange College | |
Southern Association of Schools and Colleges
| Alabama | North Carolina |
| Oakwood College | St. Augustine's College |
| Stillman College | Barber-Scotia College |
| Talladega College | Lees-McRae College |
| University of Mobile | South Carolina |
| Florida | Claflin University (x2)
|
| Palm Beach Atlantic College | Morris College |
| Warner University (x2) | Newberry College
|
| St. Thomas University | Voorhees College |
| Edward Waters College (x2) | Tennessee |
| Carlos Albizu University (x2) | Bethel College |
| Kentucky | LeMoyne-Owen College |
| Midway College | Mid-Continent Baptist College |
Mississippi
| King College |
Mississippi Valley State University
| Texas |
| Virginia | Lubbock Christian University |
| Saint Paul's College | Wiley College |
| Virginia Intermont College | Texas College |
Western Association of Colleges and Schools
| California | |
| Christian Heritage College | Biola University |
| Patten College | Hope International University
|
Northwest Association of Colleges and Schools
| Montana | Oregon |
| Rocky Mountain College | Northwest Christian College |
| Washington | Warner Pacific College |
| Henry Cogswell College | Concordia University |
| Northwest College | |
International Schools and Colleges
| Canada | West Indies |
| Atlantic Baptist University | The University of the West Indies |